Asphalt Shingle — 3-Tab
The budget standard: flat, uniform shingles with the shortest service life of any material we price.
Worked example: a 24-square roof at the national band runs $8,400 – $11,400 installed, including tear-off of one layer, underlayment, and standard flashing. In Washington, labor adjusts that to $8,900 – $12,050.
Pros
- Lowest installed cost of any roofing material
- Lightweight — suits almost any structure
- Fast, widely available installation
Cons
- Shortest lifespan (15-20 years)
- First to lift in high wind
- Fewer color and texture choices
Best for: Budget replacements, rentals, and homes likely to be sold within a decade.
Sources: Angi (2026 cost data): Asphalt installed $400-$800 per square overall; 3-tab at the bottom of the asphalt range; HomeGuide (2025): Asphalt 3-tab $3-$5 per sq ft installed ($300-$500 per square); This Old House / Homewyse (2026): Asphalt shingles $5.16 per sq ft average across grades ($516 per square). Full sourcing on the methodology page.
Asphalt Shingle — Architectural
The most common replacement in America: thicker, dimensional shingles with a 25-30 year life.
Worked example: a 24-square roof at the national band runs $10,800 – $16,200 installed, including tear-off of one layer, underlayment, and standard flashing. In Washington, labor adjusts that to $11,400 – $17,100.
Pros
- Best cost-per-year of any common material
- Dimensional look suits most home styles
- Widely stocked — fast scheduling
Cons
- Algae streaking in humid climates without resistant granules
- Not a lifetime roof — plan on one more replacement
- Wind rating varies by product line
Best for: Most homeowners: the default balance of price, life, and curb appeal.
Sources: Angi (2026 cost data): Architectural planning figure $400-$800 per square installed; Homewyse (May 2026): Composition (laminated shingle) roof installed $620-$802 per square; Peer calculator tables (2026): Architectural asphalt $411-$666 per square installed. Full sourcing on the methodology page.
Price your own roof with the free satellite estimator or the manual calculator — same dataset, your measurements.